At 8 a.m. on Monday, August 17, two days before the official opening, a line was already waiting outside the new Tartine at Strawberry Village. By 8:30 the café was full. The Ark reported that riders had come over by bike from Kentfield and San Rafael. A Mill Valley couple who had been buying Tartine in San Francisco for years told the paper they had followed the opening on Instagram. The cashier said the bakery had sold out of baked goods within a few hours on both of the two previous days.
Most of the coverage called it a homecoming, and it is one. Before Tartine became the Mission District bakery with lines around the block, Chad Robertson and Elisabeth Prueitt baked in Mill Valley. Their bakery was at 17 Madrona Street, a short walk from the Depot. Today that history spans two addresses. Tartine's loaves arrive at Strawberry Village from San Francisco, while 17 Madrona still has a wood-fired oven. Your Thanksgiving bread order depends on which counter you choose.
The Country Loaf at Strawberry Comes Over the Bridge
Tartine Mill Valley sits at 800 Redwood Highway Frontage Road, Suite 125, in the stretch of Strawberry Village with Safeway, Calico Corners and High Tech Burrito. It took over two storefronts that had stood empty for years, 3,091 square feet in all. Studio BBA designed the space with high ceilings and seating for 120 indoors and out, and the bakers work in view of the customers. It is open daily from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m.
What you buy there comes from two places. The Ark reported that the bread is baked in San Francisco and delivered daily, while the pastries are made on site at Strawberry. The morning buns, croissants and seasonal pastries come out of the kitchen you can watch from the counter. The country loaf, the bread general manager Derek Belanger told Marin Magazine "launched the entire business," is one of the loaves on that daily delivery.
Some of the menu is made for Mill Valley. Belanger said this is the only Tartine location outside an urban area, which makes parking easier. He also described a Danish with peaches and Cowgirl Creamery's Mt. Tam cheese that is sold only at this store. If you're avoiding wheat, the bakery uses flour on the premises and labels its flour-free items as wheat free. Those include muffins made with oat flour, almond meal and brown rice flour, coconut macaroons, and cherry oatmeal and salted chocolate buckwheat cookies.
Seventeen Madrona Kept Baking After They Left
Robertson and Prueitt came to Mill Valley from Point Reyes. They learned under Alan Scott, the West Marin oven builder widely credited with reviving brick, wood-burning ovens, and they started their bakery with a loan from him. "Alan is why we all ended up there," Robertson told Marin Magazine in 2016. "He was about forming a community around the oven."
Marin Magazine places their move to 17 Madrona in 2000. They stayed two years and then left to open the first Tartine in the Mission in 2002. A Marin Independent Journal correspondent remembered the bakery's rustic loaves, its croque monsieur and the bread baking in the wood-fired oven where customers could see it.
The room has been built around an oven ever since. In the same Marin Magazine story, restaurateur Ged Robertson, who is behind Shoreline Coffee Shop and Watershed, described what followed:
- Another tenant moved in after Bay Village.
- Ged Robertson opened Small Shed Flatbreads there around 2004.
- Molina followed in 2014.
- Bootjack Woodfired came next, and he later sold it to its next owners.
- Gemma Edward Aron and Nicola Carey opened Madrona Bakery in 2023.
The Tartine link carried through that whole run. Ged Robertson told the magazine that Alan Scott built him an oven and gave him Chad's books on bread. Chad stopped by during construction and gave him pizza dough tips, "which is what we still use today at Watershed."
Elvira, and a Sunday Pizza Window
The original Alan Scott oven is gone. Madrona Bakery bakes in its replacement, nicknamed Elvira, which Malcolm Chase built in Scott's style. Chase learned the craft from Scott. The bakery describes its focus as laminated pastry, wood-fired sourdough and specialty coffee.
Since October, Elvira has also been baking pizza. The Mill Valley Chamber of Commerce reports that Madrona serves wood-fired pizza on Sunday afternoons from noon until about 2. The pizzas come from head bread baker David Torres, who used to run pizza nights at The Mill in San Francisco. There is a margherita and a rotating seasonal pie, sold by the slice or whole. You can't preorder pizza. You order at the counter, and it comes out in about 20 minutes. The Chamber suggests taking a whole pie to the Depot or down to Old Mill Park.
So pizza dough is back in the oven room where Small Shed Flatbreads and Bootjack Woodfired once baked. For an afternoon outside, Madrona also pours beer and wine. According to Madrona Bakery's website, dogs are welcome at the outdoor seating, though the health department has asked the bakery to keep them out of the indoor space. Service animals are the exception. For more places to bring a dog around town, see our Mill Valley dog guide.
Thanksgiving Week, Two Counters
The two bakeries handle holiday orders differently, and their hours differ too. Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, November 26.
Tartine Mill Valley | Madrona Bakery | |
|---|---|---|
Address | 800 Redwood Hwy Frontage Rd, Suite 125 | 17 Madrona St. |
Regular hours | Daily, 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. | Thu and Fri 7:30 a.m. to 3 p.m.; Sat and Sun 8 a.m. to 3 p.m.; closed Mon to Wed |
Where the bread is baked | San Francisco, delivered daily | On site, wood-fired |
Holiday ordering | Holiday preorders through the Mill Valley holiday menu, pickup only | Online preorders only; Thanksgiving-day seeded levain due by Sunday, Nov. 22 |
At Tartine, holiday preorders are open at every location, and some items are also sold to walk-in customers. The Mill Valley holiday menu is pickup only. Pumpkin, apple and pecan-chocolate rye are 9-inch pies at $59 each, and a whole vegetarian quiche is $65. Petite pumpkin and lemon-pistachio-cranberry tea cakes are $15.50 each, and a glazed gingerbread tile is $5.75. The breads are the country sourdough at $14.95 and the oat porridge and sesame loaves at $15.50.
At Madrona, the Thanksgiving loaf is the seeded levain at $12.50. Preorder it by November 22 and pick it up on Thanksgiving Day at 17 Madrona. The bakery takes everyday preorders online only, at least one day ahead, and doesn't take orders or check stock by email, phone or text. It's also cashless, though cash tips are welcome.
Madrona's regular week opens Thursday and runs through Sunday. The seeded levain preorder closes on Sunday, November 22, the last day of the bakery's open week before Thanksgiving.
After the Holiday, the Classes
Madrona has posted its Fall/Winter 2026–27 baking classes, and most of the season is still ahead:
- Cookie-making: Friday, December 4
- Sourdough for the home baker: Saturday, December 5; Saturday, January 16; Saturday, February 27
- Focaccia: Saturday, December 12; Saturday, January 30; Saturday, March 13
- Quick breads, scones and biscuits: Saturday, January 23, 4 to 6 p.m., $115; Saturday, February 20
The earlier focaccia classes on October 3 and November 7 sold out. A sourdough class at 17 Madrona carries the lesson from Alan Scott's West Marin to the room where Robertson and Prueitt first baked in town.
Back at Strawberry Village, Tartine's neighbor down the corridor is Cholita Linda in Suite 801. It serves Latin American street food daily from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. It's the place to go once the pastry case is empty. For more on how Strawberry Village has become a regular stop on the town calendar, see our look at Mill Valley's fall traditions.
Wherever your Thanksgiving loaf comes from, we'd love to hear which counter you chose, and we're glad to share our own favorites from 17 Madrona and Strawberry Village. Contact Team Brody for more local finds like these from people who have been buying bread in this town for a long time.